Collective punishment and reward are usually regarded as two potential mechanisms to explain the evolution of cooperation. Both scenarios, however, seem problematic to understand cooperative behavior, because they can raise the second-order free-rider problem and many organisms are not able to discriminate less cooperating individuals.
Even though they have been proved to increase cooperation, there has been a debate about which one being more effective. To address this issue, researchers resort to the N-player evolutionary snowdrift game (NESG), where a collective punishment/reward mechanism is added by allowing some players to display punishment/reward towards all remaining players.
By means of numerous simulations and analyses, authors find that collective punishment is more effective in promoting cooperation for a relatively high initial frequency of cooperation or for a relatively small group.
When the intensity of punishment exceeds a certain threshold, a stable state of full cooperation emerges for both small and large groups.
In contrast, such state does not appear for large groups playing a NESG with reward mechanism. In the case of mutualistic interactions, finally, the results show the new payoff with collective punishment/reward can lead to the coexistence of cooperators and defectors when discrimination between these two is not possible.
http://www.nature.com/articles/srep17752
Edited
Latest News
Cells mechanical forces linked to immune system
Characterization of a new Leishmania major strain for use in a controlled human infection model
Stress granules do not suppress mRNA translation!
How the brain paralyzes you while you sleep
Strong link between gut microbes, diet and health in humans
Other Top Stories
Junk DNA in fat cells plays a role in obesity
Neural circuit controlling hunger identified!
Mitochondria controls nucleus during metabolic stress
Mice study implicates fat as obesity cause
Positive results in human clinical trials with verapamil to treat type I diabetes
Protocols
Dual-Angle Protocol for Doppler Optical Coherence Tomography to Improve Retinal Blood Flow Measur…
Detection of protein SUMOylation in vivo
In vivo analysis of protein sumoylation induced by a viral protein: Detection of HCMV pp71-induce…
Determination of SUMOylation sites
miR-Selection 3'UTR Target Selection Kit
Publications
Mechanical Stiffness Controls Dendritic Cell Metabolism and Function
Characterization of a new Leishmania major strain for use in a controlled human infection model
Serum biomarkers in primary mitochondrial disorders
Stearoyl-CoA Desaturase-Mediated Monounsaturated Fatty Acid Availability Supports Humoral Immunity
Monocytes carrying GFAP detect glioma, brain metastasis and ischaemic stroke, and predict gliobla…
Presentations
Homeostasis
PLANT MITOCHONDRIAL BIOLOGY
Photosynthesis
Endocrine Disorders
THE PITUITARY GLAND
Posters
ACMT 2020 Annual Scientific Meeting Abstracts - New York, NY
Abstracts from the 2020 Annual Scientific Meeting of the British and Irish Hypertension Society (…
ACNP 58th Annual Meeting: Poster Session III
ACNP 58th Annual Meeting: Poster Session II
ACNP 58th Annual Meeting: Poster Session I