Taxing sugar-sweetened beverages by the amount of sugar they contain, rather than by the liquid volume of these drinks, as several U.S. cities currently do, could produce even greater health benefits and economic gains, a team of researchers has concluded. The analysis appears in the journal Science.
Seven U.S. cities currently tax sugar-sweetened beverages, or SSBs, by the volume of the beverage--levies that don't take into account the amount of sugar these drinks contain.
"Despite their different sugar content and resulting different harms, all sugar-sweetened beverages are taxed at the same rate per liter under a volumetric tax," write the author. "This tax structure gives consumers no incentive to substitute from high-sugar to low-sugar SSBs, even though the latter are less harmful. Thus, while a volumetric tax reduces consumption of SSBs in general, it does not provide the maximum possible health benefits."
"A basic economic principle is that such corrective taxes should be proportional to the harm caused," the authors add. "The harm from sugary drinks comes from the sugar, and SSBs vary substantially in sugar per unit volume."
The researchers note, however, that a tax on liquid volume is beneficial. They estimate, for instance, that a 34-cent per liter volumetric tax causes the average U.S. adult to drink 2.9 fewer ounces of SSBs per day, a 22-percent reduction. This decrease in sugar intake would help the average adult to lose 2.3 pounds. In addition, a nationwide volumetric SSB tax would reduce obesity rates by 2 percent--a 2.1 million decline in adults with obesity--and would lower the number of new Type 2 diabetes cases by 2.3 percent, or approximately 36,000 new cases per year.
They add that such a tax would also result in economic gains--primarily through savings in health care costs--of about $1.4 billion per year nationwide.
However, in their assessment, a tax on the amount of sugar in SSBs would yield even greater health and economic gains. Such a tax would cause U.S. adults to consume 2.3 fewer grams of sugar per day from SSBs than they would under a volumetric tax, helping the average adult lose an additional 0.7 pounds. Across the U.S., a sugar tax instead of a volumetric tax would reduce obesity rates by an additional 630,000 adults and would cut the number of new Type 2 diabetes cases by another 0.7 percent--or approximately 11,000 people per year. Moreover, the additional annual economic gain would be another $400 million.
"Once there is agreement to tax SSBs, it seems natural to tax the harmful sugar, instead of the liquid that comes with the sugar," the authors conclude. "Our calculations suggest that this idea offers valuable low-hanging fruit for improving public health."
A previous study concluded that soda taxes serve as a "net good," an assessment based on an examination of health benefits and consumer behavior. That analysis, which appeared in the Quarterly Journal of Economics earlier this year, estimated that a nationwide soda tax would yield $7 billion in net benefits to society each year.
https://science.sciencemag.org/content/365/6457/989
Latest News
A personalized neuromodulation approach to severe depression
Fast, fully automated software constructs accurate models of protein structure
Plasma MT-DNA test identifies COVID-19 patients at high risk of severe disease
Restricted diet and glucose uptake in the brain lead to longer life
Pixelated chemical displays offer versatile liquid handling
Other Top Stories
Controlling bacterial subpopulation culture densities autonomously
Iron deficiency conditions like anemia may contribute to the spread of dengue fever
Immunological protection by mutated Ebola virus in monkeys
Interactions between bacteria and parasites changes immune response
Modified pantothenamides inhibit acetylCo-A in malaria parasites
Protocols
Dual-Angle Protocol for Doppler Optical Coherence Tomography to Improve Retinal Blood Flow Measur…
Detection of protein SUMOylation in vivo
In vivo analysis of protein sumoylation induced by a viral protein: Detection of HCMV pp71-induce…
Determination of SUMOylation sites
miR-Selection 3'UTR Target Selection Kit
Publications
Expert programmers have fine-tuned cortical representations of source code
Cellular, molecular, and clinical mechanisms of action of deep brain stimulation–a systematic rev…
DeepTracer for fast de novo cryo-EM protein structure modeling and special studies on CoV-related…
Circulating mitochondrial DNA is an early indicator of severe illness and mortality from COVID-19
Neural correlates of shared sensory symptoms in autism and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder
Presentations
Homeostasis
PLANT MITOCHONDRIAL BIOLOGY
Photosynthesis
Endocrine Disorders
THE PITUITARY GLAND
Posters
ACMT 2020 Annual Scientific Meeting Abstracts - New York, NY
Abstracts from the 2020 Annual Scientific Meeting of the British and Irish Hypertension Society (…
ACNP 58th Annual Meeting: Poster Session III
ACNP 58th Annual Meeting: Poster Session II
ACNP 58th Annual Meeting: Poster Session I